DelhiScoop.com
HOME | TOURISM | INFO TECH | NEWS | REAL ESTATE | HEALTH | INFRASTRUCTURE | EDUCATION | CONTACT US - SANJAY @ 98 119 87371

Singur Made A Rs 76 Crore Hole In West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation (WBIDC) Pocket: CAG


By siddharth22, Section News
Posted on Thu Mar 27, 2008 at 11:55:18 PM EST

The CAG report for the year ending March 2007 has revealed that West Bengal Industrial Development Corporation (WBIDC) has incurred a loss of Rs 76.11 crore by subsidising the lease of the land granted to Tata Motors Limited (TML) for setting up its Rs 1 lakh car unit at Singur.
The report adds that the loss should have been borne by the state government rather than WBIDC, which is not a subordinate office of the government.

On the directive of the state government, the WBIDC acquired 1,006.45 acres of land at Singur, of which it leased out 645.67 acres to Tata Motors'. A portion of the remaining land, 190.44 acres, was leased out to 30 vendors of the TML. Another 70.78 acres were waterbodies and land meant for internal roads, sub-stations etc.

The corporation leased the land to TML for a period of 90 years at a value of Rs 96.72 crore. As per government directive for long-term leases, the lessee (Tata Motors in this case) should pay 95 per cent of the market value of the land as one term premium (salami) on the commencement of the lease. An annual rent at the rate of 0.3 per cent of the market value of the land would also have to be paid.

"The present value of aggregate of premium (Rs 91.88 crore) and cumulative annual lease rent (Rs 2.85 crore) comes to Rs 94.73 crore, at a discount factor of 10 per cent. Against this, the present value of cumulative lease rent of Rs 855.75 crore payable by TML over 90 years works out to Rs 18.62 crores at the same discount factor, entailing loss of Rs 76.11 crore to the WBIDC over the entire lease period," the report states.

To this the WBIDC said that the discount was made as part of the "special incentive package" announced by the government for the TML.

The clarification was forwarded to the CAG by WBIDC management.

The CAG noted: "The management stated that the terms and conditions of the lease had been drawn in pursuance to special incentive package, decided by government for the TML. The contention is not tenable because (1) according to the company, WBIDC is not a subordinate office of the state government. Hence, the subsidy, if any, to be passed on to the TML should have been borne by the government and not by the company, which was already burdened with the liability to repay the loan and interest from its own fund at the instance of the government and (2) the details of special incentive package were not furnished to Audit though called for."

The CAG also observed that the WBIDC had drawn excess loan than required which led to an additional interest burden of Rs 1.44 crore between September 2006 and July 2007.

The WBIDC also placed funds to the tune of Rs 1.55 crore for disbursal as delayed "consent awards". The CAG states that under the Land Acquisition Act 1894, there was no provision for payment of additional compensation when the landowners had already agreed to the valuation of the Land Acquisition Collector.

Source:The Indian Express,28-03-08

< Medical College To Come Up In North 24-Parganas In Kolkata | Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta (IIM-C) Engaged In Implementing Hindi As Official Language >
Display: Sort:
Display: Sort:
Win A Jeans Twice a Week
&
Win A Kurta 7 Days A Week
MEMBERS AREA

Make a new account

Username:
Password:
 ACTION CENTER

Internet Services

Who's Online? (5)

. Unregistered Visitors (5)

Note: You may cloak yourself from appearing here in your Display Preferences.

Site Stats

No Access

Recent Comments

. GOOD ATTEMPT (khurshid anwar)

. Private investment is must for countries growth (khurshid anwar)

. comment (syeedunsyd)

. comment (syeedunsyd)

. Gift Tax (Mrs Gupta)

. DTDC (tanay253)

Recent Member Diaries


More Diaries...

Front Page

Tuesday January 6th
. Kolkata Municipal Corporation Decided to Issue Identity Cards To Hawkers Of The City (0 comments)
. Governor For Better Education System (0 comments)
. West Bengal Tourism to organise Sixth Tourism and Food Festival in Kolkata (0 comments)

Monday January 5th
. Zilla Parishad (ZP) Diverts Development Funds For Road Repairs (0 comments)
. city's Metro Railway To Switch From Tickets To Tokens (0 comments)

Sunday January 4th
. Zero Stamp Duty For Special Eonomic Zones And SEZ Units Under Lens (0 comments)
. Chinese Construction Majors Eye Bengal Collaboration (0 comments)
. Bengal Finalising Master Plan For Newtown (0 comments)
. Real Estate: Correct Time To Innovate (0 comments)
. Despite Recession Serviced Offices Gain Popularity (0 comments)

Friday January 2nd
. Online Power: Stay Home, Pick IIT Mentors' Brains Spread Across The Country (0 comments)
. CM Wants Rs 255-cr Central Fund To Strengthen City Police (0 comments)
. Jadavpur University (JU) Fixes Fees For Foreign Students (0 comments)
. Riverbank To Set Up Marina Hotel On The Bank Of River At Batanagar By 2013 (0 comments)
. Job Slump? Good News For Job Seekers, Companies To Hire 2,50,000 In Next Few Months (0 comments)

Thursday January 1st
. Infrastructure Plans Stall As Developers Shy Away From Bids (0 comments)
. Retailers Expect To Gain From Falling Rentals,Focus On Special Segments This Year (0 comments)
. ICICI Slashes Home Loan Rate - EXISTING CUSTOMERS WILL BE BENEFITED TOO (0 comments)
. The Real Estate Market - 2009 (0 comments)

Tuesday December 30th
. Oversupply In Commercial Real Estate Likely To Continue in 2009: Cushman & Wakefield (0 comments)
. Plan To Turn Kolkata's 186-year-Old Mint Into India's First Currency Suseum Stalls (0 comments)

Monday December 29th
. Rs 1,947 cr For Kolkata Airport's Makeover (0 comments)
. Jai Balaji Gets 750 acres For Integrated Steel ,Power And Cement Plant In Purulia (0 comments)
. Garbage Power In Civic Recycle Bin (0 comments)
. Tourism Plan To Save Wetland,Develop Eco-Tourism To Stop Illegal Constructions,Civic Body Tells Govt (0 comments)

Older Stories...


All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest (c) GurgaonSCOOP.com and QBTPL.
submit story | create account | faq | search