DelhiScoop.com
HOME | TOURISM | INFO TECH | NEWS | REAL ESTATE | HEALTH | INFRASTRUCTURE | EDUCATION | CONTACT US - SANJAY @ 98 119 87371

Quota Limit Can't Exceed 50 Per Cent Cap: Supreme Court


By Dr arvind, Section News
Posted on Sat Jul 28, 2007 at 03:25:51 AM EST

Even as a constitution Bench is set to examine the validity of the new central law extending quota for OBCs in admission to government institutions next month, the Supreme Court today once again affirmed that the 50 per cent cap imposed by it on reservation cannot be violated in any manner.

This was held by a Bench of Justices A.K. Mathur and Dalveer Bhandari while dismissing an appeal of the Orissa government seeking to justify its reservation scheme providing for enhanced quota limit of 65.75 per cent in the state.

Orissa after Tamil Nadu was the second state to increase the reservation beyond 50 per cent cap, fixed by the apex court in the Mandal Commission case judgement and reiterated in last year's Nagraj case verdict on reservation in promotion in public employment.

As per the break-up given by the Orissa government, the quota in the state was fixed at 22.5 per cent to Scheduled Tribes, 16.5 per cent to Scheduled Castes and 27 per cent to Other Backward Classes.

The state government moved the apex court after the Orissa High Court, in its April 17 order, had rejected its first appeal against the Administrative Tribunal's order of 1998, refusing to recognise appointments to state civil services under the new quota scheme beyond 50 per cent limit in view of the clear-cut guidelines of the apex court.

After the Mandal case judgement, the Orissa government, in April 1994, had issued a notification fixing the OBC reservation at 11.25 per cent to make the total reservation at 50 per cent. But the OBC quota was extended to 27 per cent in December the same year by inserting an exception clause in the notification, stating that the raise of 15.75 per cent would be beyond the Mandal case verdict of the apex court.

Both the Administrative Tribunal and the high court had rejected such a stand of the state government.

The apex court is already examining the violation of 50 per cent cap by Tamil Nadu, which had put its law in the Ninth Schedule, taking it out of judicial review.

But the apex court, in its historic judgement last year, had held that any law which hit at the basic structure of the Constitution was subject to judicial review. In view of the ruling, the court is now examining the validity of the Tamil Nadu reservation law also.

Source- TRIBUNE, July-28, 2007

< No pesky calls from Sept 5, Telemarketers to pay Rs 1,000 fine for first violation | ITC Abandons Rs 15,000-crore West Bengal Plans >
Display: Sort:
Display: Sort:
Win A Jeans Twice a Week
&
Win A Kurta 7 Days A Week
MEMBERS AREA

Make a new account

Username:
Password:
 ACTION CENTER

Internet Services

Who's Online? (10)

. Unregistered Visitors (10)

Note: You may cloak yourself from appearing here in your Display Preferences.

Site Stats

No Access

Recent Comments

. GOOD ATTEMPT (khurshid anwar)

. Private investment is must for countries growth (khurshid anwar)

. comment (syeedunsyd)

. comment (syeedunsyd)

. Gift Tax (Mrs Gupta)

. DTDC (tanay253)

Recent Member Diaries


More Diaries...

Front Page

Tuesday August 12th
. 350 Tech Seats Vacant in Engineering Colleges In State- Students Blame Centralised System For Fiasco (0 comments)
. Plan panel pulls up govt for tardy pace of work (0 comments)
. 4-Lane Artery Parallel To VIP Road In Baguiati To Ease Traffic Load Between Airport And Ultadanga (0 comments)
. Bus Bays That Hold Up Traffic And Ignore The Bays Creating,More Snarls On The Narrowed Carriageways (0 comments)
. For Pujas, Darjeeling to get a break from bandhs (0 comments)
. Rs 24-cr plan to revamp the ghats of Ganga, promote river tourism (0 comments)
. With solar power plant for Raj Bhavan, Governor leads the way again (0 comments)
. Calcutta Medical College And Hospital To Get Status Upgrade Like AIMS,But Lack Treatment Facilities (0 comments)
. Work On Modernisation Of Kolkata Airports Will Start Next Month (0 comments)

Monday August 11th
. Real estate prices set to shoot up in Kolkata,Non-residents homing in thick & fast (0 comments)
. Carry Bags That Are Not Only Bio-Degradable, But Are Actually Green In Colour at city malls soon (0 comments)
. Darjeeling Municipality Passed A Resolution To Sanction Buildings Up To Four Storeys (0 comments)
. Youths To Man Traffic On Accident-Prone Arteries (0 comments)
. A 12-Hour Hills Shutdown On August 22 Bad News For Hill Tourists (0 comments)

Sunday August 10th
. Realty Bytes: Indian Realty Sector Breaking New Ground, In Its Adoption Of Information Technology (0 comments)

Saturday August 9th
. Tallest In Town & Country, 250m Office Tower In Heart Of City On Chowringhee,Next to Tata Centre (0 comments)
. Cabs On Call: Dial The Number And Take An AC Ride Anywhere In City (0 comments)
. Sops For Green Switch: Give Rs 10,000 To Each Autorickshaw Owner For Switching To LPG (0 comments)
. Madrasas To Be Upgraded To Formal Education Centres In North Dinajpur District (0 comments)
. GM India Ties Up With IIT Kharagpur For Joint Research In Areas Of Electronics,Controls And Software (0 comments)
. No Govt Vehicle Plying With GL (Gorkhaland) Number Plate, Says District Magistrate (0 comments)

Friday August 8th
. Lalu Nod To North-South MetroTo Dakshineswar Extension Project (0 comments)
. KMC Chips To Check Illegal Hoardings, To Keep Track Of Illegal Advertising In The City (0 comments)
. Genpact To Recruit 7000 In Kolkata With Unitech By Build A 7,000-People Office In Kolkata (0 comments)

Thursday August 7th
. Kolkata Municipal Corporation Forms Plan To Save Parks From Encroachers (0 comments)

Older Stories...


All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest (c) GurgaonSCOOP.com and QBTPL.
submit story | create account | faq | search